| Name | Rarity | Origin | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ace Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Ace Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Acorn Plushie | Common | Fall Weather Update | |
| Agender Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Agender Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Airplane Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Amber Bone | Uncommon | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Ammonite Frisbee | Uncommon | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Anchor Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Angelic Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Angelic Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Anhk Pogostick | Ultra-Rare | Desert Weather Map | |
| Anna Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Antler Chew Toy | Uncommon | Unreleased | |
| Anvil Balloon | Common | Gifts | |
| Armchair Float | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Aromantic Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Aromantic Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Astro Ball | Ultra-Rare | Pet Shop | |
| Axe Rattle | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 | |
| Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Balloons | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Banana Chew Toy | Common | Gorilla Box | |
| Banana Leaf Balloon | Uncommon | Gorilla Box | |
| Banana Plush | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Banana Pogo | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Banana Rattle | Common | Baby Shop | |
| Banana Tree Pogo Stick | Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Banjo | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 | |
| Bat Key Pogo Stick | Rare | Gifts | |
| Bat Wing Balloon | Uncommon | Halloween 2022 | |
| Bauble Balloon | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Bench | Uncommon | Camping Store | |
| Bi Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Bi Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Big Log Throw Toy | Uncommon | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Bone Throw Toy | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Bone Xylophone | Rare | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Bongos | Uncommon | Campground | |
| Boomerang Throw Toy | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Bouncy Ball Pogo | Rare | Gifts | |
| Briefcase Ingredient | Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Bubblegum Machine Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Bumblebee Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Bumblebee Pogo Stick | Rare | Gifts | |
| Bunny Plush | Uncommon | Easter 2019 | |
| Burger Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Cactus Balloon | Ultra-Rare | Desert Weather Map | |
| Cactus Friend | Uncommon | Desert Weather Map | |
| Cactus Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Cactus Plushie Chew Toy | Common | Gifts | |
| Camera | Uncommon | Influencer Update | |
| Camper's Bench | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camper's Bongos | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camper's Flashlight | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camper's Guitar | Rare | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camper's Sleeping Bag | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camper's Sparkler | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camper's Tent | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Camping Tent | Uncommon | Camping Store | |
| Candle | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Candy Cane Chew Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2020 | |
| Candy Cane Grappling Hook | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Candy Cane Ornament | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Candy Cane Pogo Stick | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Candy Cane Throw Toy | Uncommon | Unreleased | |
| Candy Cannon | Legendary | Halloween 2018 (Robux) | |
| Captain's Wheel Throw Toy | Common | Rain Weather Update | |
| Carousel Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Carrot Friend Plushie | Common | Easter 2022 | |
| Carrot Pogo Stick | Rare | Easter 2022 | |
| Carrot Rattle | Uncommon | Easter 2019 | |
| Cat Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Caticorn Rattle | Common | Gifts | |
| CD Throwing Disc | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Celestial Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Celestial Leash | Common | Gifts | |
| Celestial Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Chainsaw Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Chew Ball | Common | Gifts | |
| Chick Plush | Rare | Easter 2019 | |
| Chinese Lantern | Uncommon | Chinese New Year 2018 | |
| Chocolate Bunny Balloon | Rare | Easter 2019 | |
| Christmas Ball Ornament | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Christmas Cat Rattle | Rare | Gifts | |
| Christmas Doge Rattle | Common | Christmas 2017 | |
| Christmas Star Frisbee | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Cinnamon Stick | Common | Fall Weather Update | |
| Claw | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Clouds & Rainbow Rattle | Rare | Baby Shop | |
| Clover Balloon | Common | Gifts | |
| Clown Umbrella | Uncommon | Monkey Fairground | |
| Controller Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Cookie Dough Plush | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Cookie Frisbee | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Cool Frisbee | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Cotton Candy Stand | Ultra-Rare | Cotton Candy Stand Gamepass (Robux) | |
| Creator Rattle - Bethink | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Creator Rattle - NewFissy | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Creepy Balloon | Common | Halloween 2019 | |
| Croc Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Crook Throw Toy | Uncommon | Desert Weather Map | |
| Crossbow Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2019 | |
| Crow's Nest Balloon | Common | Rain Weather Update | |
| Crown Frisbee | Rare | Gifts | |
| Crystal Ball Rattle | Uncommon | Halloween 2020 | |
| Cymbal Ingredient | Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Da Vinci Propeller | Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Daisy Flying Disc | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Dandelion Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Spring Festival 2020 | |
| Demi Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Demi Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Desert Drum | Rare | Desert Weather Map | |
| Didgeridoo | Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Discosplosion | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Dog Food Frisbee | Common | Gifts | |
| Dog Leash | Rare | Gifts | |
| Doge Rattle | Common | Baby Shop | |
| Donut Frisbee | Rare | Gifts | |
| Donut Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Donut Throw Toy | Ultra-Rare | Pet Shop | |
| Dragon Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Drone Propeller | Uncommon | Star Rewards | |
| Drooping Orchid Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Duck Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Duck Rattle | Common | Baby Shop | |
| Easter Bunny Plush | Rare | Easter 2019 | |
| Eclipse Balloon | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Eclipse Flying Disc | Rare | Gifts | |
| Egg Rattle | Uncommon | Easter 2018 | |
| Elephant Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Elf Ornament | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Elf Plush | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Elf Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Enby Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Enby Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Eyeball Rattle | Common | Halloween 2020 | |
| Fairground Pogo | Common | Gorilla Box | |
| Fairy Rose Light Rattle | Common | Gifts | |
| Fall Corn Grappling Hook | Legendary | Fall Weather Update | |
| Fall Rains Balloon | Rare | Fall Weather Update | |
| Fan Flying Disc | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2022 | |
| Fancy Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Fancy Umbrella | Rare | Gifts | |
| Fern Propeller | Legendary | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Ferris Wheel Propeller | Rare | Halloween 2019 | |
| Festive Bells Balloon | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Festive Holly Propeller | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Festive Snow Globe Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Figgy Pudding Chew Toy | Common | Christmas 2021 | |
| Finger Piano | Rare | Fall Weather Update | |
| Fishing Tackle Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Flame Balloon | Uncommon | Campfire Cookie | |
| Flame Grappling Hook | Common | Campfire Cookie | |
| Flame Pogostick | Common | Campfire Cookie | |
| Flashlight | Uncommon | Campground | |
| Flipflop Throw Toy | Common | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Floatie Raft | Common | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Floaties | Common | Pool Store | |
| Floppy Bunny Plushie | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Flower Cloud Plush | Rare | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Flower Frisbee | Uncommon | Spring Festival 2020 | |
| Flower Mirror Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Flower Rattle | Common | Gifts | |
| Flying Broomstick | Legendary | Halloween 2018 | |
| Flying Disc Umbrella | Common | Gifts | |
| Flying Saucer Disc | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Football Pet Toy | Rare | Pet Shop | |
| Founder's Key Throw Toy | Uncommon | Sunken Ship | |
| Frisbee | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Frostbite Grapple | Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Fun Frisbee | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Futuristic Grapple | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Futuristic Turbine Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Galaxy Flying Disc | Common | Gifts | |
| Galaxy Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Gay Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Gay Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Gay Man Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Gay Man Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Gender Fluid Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Gender Fluid Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Gender Queer Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Gender Queer Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Gift Stack Pogo Stick | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Gift Throw Toy | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Gingerbread Balloon | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Bear Balloon | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Face Flying Disc | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Gingerbread Heart Flying Disc | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Gingerbread Holly Flying Disc | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread House Throw Toy | Common | Christmas 2021 | |
| Gingerbread Kitty Throw Toy | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Leash | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Pogo Stick | Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Rattle | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Star Propeller | Legendary | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Stocking Toy | Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Gingerbread Wreath Flying Disc | Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Glider | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Glyptoball | Uncommon | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Gold Star | Ultra-Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Golden Goblet | Legendary | Premium Gorilla Box | |
| Golden Maned Unicorn Rattle | Ultra-Rare | Baby Shop | |
| Grapplenana | Ultra-Rare | Rain Weather Update | |
| Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Toy Shop | |
| Griffin Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Guitar | Rare | Campground | |
| Halloween Black Bat Propeller | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Black Victorian Candlestick Rattle | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Orange Pumpkin Balloon | Common | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Orange Pumpkin Flying Disc | Common | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Orange Pumpkin Voodoo Doll | Rare | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween White Ghost Balloon | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Wooden Scythe Grappling Hook | Rare | Halloween 2021 | |
| Hang Glider Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Harp Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Heart Balloon | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Heart Plushie | Common | Valentine's 2018 | |
| Heart Rattle | Common | Valentine's 2019 | |
| Holiday Breadstick Chew Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2020 | |
| Honey Dipper Rattle | Ultra-Rare | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Horse Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Hotdog Stand | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Huggable Pillow | Common | Gifts | |
| Hugging Egg | Rare | Easter 2018 | |
| Hypnotic Frisbee | Uncommon | Monkey Fairground | |
| Ice Club Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Ice Cream Plush | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Ice Cream Rattle | Common | Gifts | |
| Ice Grapple | Legendary | Snow Weather Update | |
| Ice Pick Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Icicle Pogo Stick | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Icicle Throw Toy | Common | Unreleased | |
| Inflatable Sword | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Inner Tube | Common | Pool Store | |
| Intersex Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Intersex Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Jackhammer | Rare | Gifts | |
| Kangaroo Pogo | Rare | Gifts | |
| Key Chew Toy | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Kite Balloon | Rare | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Lavender Bundle | Uncommon | Spring Festival 2020 | |
| Lazy Float | Common | Pool Store | |
| Lead Zeppelin Balloon | Common | Gifts | |
| Leash | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Leek Chew Toy | Common | Gifts | |
| Lemonade Chew Toy | Uncommon | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Lemonade Stand | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Lesbian Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Lesbian Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Lime Slice Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Llama Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Llama Rattle | Uncommon | Baby Shop | |
| Long Neck Throw Toy | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Love Envelope Balloon | Common | Gifts | |
| Lucky Coin Flying Disc | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Lunar Lantern | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Lunar New Year Lantern | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2022 | |
| Lunar New Year Leash | Rare | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Lunar New Year Teapot Leash | Rare | Lunar New Year 2022 | |
| Lunar Pogo | Rare | Lunar New Year 2021 | |
| Lunar Rattle | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2021 | |
| Magic Door | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Magic Wand Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Magical Princess Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Magical Princess Leash | Rare | Gifts | |
| Magician's Wand Grappling Hook | Rare | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Magma Throwing Disc | Uncommon | Campfire Cookie | |
| Marsh Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Marsh Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Marshmallow Stand | Ultra-Rare | Camping Kit (Robux) | |
| Meaty Chew Toy | Common | Gifts | |
| Medieval Grapple | Uncommon | Star Rewards | |
| Mermaid Float | Uncommon | Pool Store | |
| Mermaid Propeller | Rare | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Mermaid Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Meteor Plush | Common | Campfire Cookie | |
| Money Rattle | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Monkey Pogo | Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Monkey Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Moon Viewing Bench | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year 2022 | |
| Mouse Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Mouse Leash | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Mushroom Flying Disc | Common | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Mushroom Friend Plushie | Common | Gifts | |
| Mushroom Pogo | Ultra-Rare | Fall Weather Update | |
| Newspaper Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Noob Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Octopus Plush | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Omnisex Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Omnisex Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Ornament Throw Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Paint Sealer | Legendary | Salon Update 2023 (Robux) | |
| Pan Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Pan Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Pancake Throwing Disc | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Panda Frisbee | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Panda Pal | Uncommon | Chinese New Year 2018 | |
| Paper Plane Launcher Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Party Innertube | Common | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Party Mermaid Float | Uncommon | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Party Pizza Float | Rare | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Party Pool Noodle | Common | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Peppermint Disc | Common | Christmas 2020 | |
| Phoenix Plush | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Pickle Elf Chew Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Pineapple Plush | Ultra-Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Pink Cat Balloon | Rare | Gifts | |
| Pinwheel Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Pirate Plushie | Rare | Rain Weather Update | |
| Pizza Float | Rare | Pool Store | |
| Plate of Food Disc | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Plunger Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Pogo Stick | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Poinsettia Leash | Common | Christmas 2021 | |
| Polar Bear Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Pool Noodle | Common | Pool Store | |
| Potato Chew Toy | Rare | Gifts | |
| Potion Bottle Balloon | Common | Halloween 2022 | |
| Premium Camping Tent | Ultra-Rare | Camping Kit (Robux) | |
| Premium Fire Pit | Ultra-Rare | Camping Kit (Robux) | |
| Premium Log Bench | Ultra-Rare | Camp | |
| Pride Balloons | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Pride Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Pride Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Pride Paw Flying Disc | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Pride Wand Rattle | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Princess Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Propeller | Rare | Toy Shop | |
| Protein Bottle Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Pumpkin | Rare | Halloween 2017 | |
| Pumpkin Basket Plushie | Uncommon | Halloween 2022 | |
| Pumpkin Rattle | Common | Halloween 2017 | |
| Puppy Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Rabbit Rattle | Common | Easter 2019 | |
| Rain Stick | Common | Rain Weather Update | |
| Rainbow Cake Chew Toy | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Rainbow Popsicle Friend | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Rainbow Rattle | Rare | Gifts | |
| Rainbow Wand | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Rattle | Common | Baby Shop | |
| Raw Bone | Common | Pet Shop | |
| Red Panda Cupcake Chew Toy | Uncommon | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Reindeer Leash | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Reindeer Ornament | Legendary | Christmas 2019 | |
| Reindeer Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| RGB Friend | Common | RGB Reward Box | |
| RGB Leash | Uncommon | RGB Reward Box | |
| RGB Phone Throw Toy | Rare | RGB Reward Box | |
| RGB Propeller | Rare | RGB Reward Box | |
| RGB Sword Rattle | Common | RGB Reward Box | |
| Rib Guitar | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 | |
| Robo Plush 3000 | Common | Gifts | |
| Rocket Grappling Hook | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Rocket Pogo | Rare | Gifts | |
| Rolling Pin | Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Rope Chew Toy | Rare | Gifts | |
| Rose Pogo | Rare | Gifts | |
| Rubber Bone Throw Toy | Common | Pet Shop | |
| Rubber Chicken Rattle | Rare | Gifts | |
| Rubber Dog Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Sai | Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Sandcastle Rattle | Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Santa Leash | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Santa Ornament | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Santa Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Satellite Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Scarab Crossbow Grappling Hook | Legendary | Desert Weather Map | |
| Scroll Ingredient | Ultra-Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Selfie Stick | Common | Influencer Update | |
| Ship Wheel Flying Disc | Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Ship's Mast Pogo | Rare | Rain Weather Update | |
| Shoe Chew Toy | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Shuttle Pogo | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Skeleton Pogo Stick | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 | |
| Ski Pole Pogo | Ultra-Rare | Snow Weather Update | |
| Skull Drum | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 | |
| Skull Propeller | Rare | Halloween 2022 | |
| Sleeping Bag | Uncommon | Camping Store | |
| Sleigh Bell Throw Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Sleigh Bells Rattle | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Snow Balloon | Ultra-Rare | Snow Weather Update | |
| Snowball Launcher | Common | Christmas 2020 | |
| Snowflake Frisbee | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Snowflake Ornament | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Snowflake Throwing Disc | Uncommon | Snow Weather Update | |
| Snowman Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Snowman Plushie Friend | Uncommon | Snow Weather Update | |
| Snowman Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Soccer Ball Throw Toy | Common | Gifts | |
| Sock Chew Toy | Common | Christmas 2019 | |
| Soda Chew Toy | Common | Gifts | |
| Space Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Sparkler | Uncommon | Campground | |
| Spider Grappling Hook | Rare | Halloween 2020 | |
| Spider Web Flying Disc | Common | Halloween 2022 | |
| Spinning Propeller | Rare | Toy Shop | |
| Spring Bunny Leash | Uncommon | Easter 2022 | |
| Sprout Pogo Stick | Ultra-Rare | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Squeaky Bone | Common | Pet Shop | |
| Squeaky Spikey | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Squid Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Squid Rattle | Uncommon | Baby Shop | |
| Staff Ingredient | Legendary | Monkey Fairground | |
| Standard Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Toy Shop | |
| Standard_Pogo | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Star & Moon Propeller | Rare | Halloween 2020 | |
| Star Ball | Rare | Pet Shop | |
| Star Balloon | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Star Ornament | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 | |
| Starpower Wand | Uncommon | Gifts | |
| Steel Drum | Uncommon | Star Rewards | |
| Stegosaurus Throw Toy | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Stick Throw Toy | Common | Gifts | |
| Strawberry Cake Roll Flying Disc | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Cakeroll Plush | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Jam Rattle | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Kitty Throw Toy | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Pogo Stick | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Rattle | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Sandwich Chew Toy | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Teapot Leash | Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Strawberry Toast Flying Disc | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Succulent Plush | Common | Gifts | |
| Sun Balloon | Common | Gifts | |
| Sunflower Rattle | Common | Spring Festival 2020 | |
| T-Rex Rattle | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| T-Rex Throw Toy | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation | |
| Tangerine Chew Toy | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2021 | |
| Tea Party Chair | Ultra-Rare | Royal Tea Party 2022 | |
| Tea Party Set | Legendary | Royal Tea Party 2022 | |
| Teddy Bear | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Teddy Skele | Rare | Halloween 2017 | |
| Telescope Pogo | Rare | Gifts | |
| Tennis Ball | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Throwing Pumpkin | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 | |
| Tombstone Ghostify | Rare | Halloween 2018 | |
| Top Hat Frisbee | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Toy Drum Flying Disc | Uncommon | Gorilla Box | |
| Transgender Flag | Uncommon | Pride Event 2022 | |
| Transgender Flag 2023 | Uncommon | Pride Update 2023 | |
| Tripod Camera | Common | Influencer Update | |
| Trumpet | Uncommon | Star Rewards | |
| Tundra Violin | Rare | Snow Weather Update | |
| Turkey Leg | Common | Gifts | |
| Turkey Plush | Uncommon | Thanksgiving 2019 | |
| Ukulele | Legendary | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Unicorn Leash | Ultra-Rare | Pet Shop | |
| Unicorn Plush | Ultra-Rare | Gifts | |
| Unicorn Rattle | Uncommon | Baby Shop | |
| Vampire Teeth Grappling Hook | Legendary | Halloween 2022 | |
| Venus Fly Trap Rattle | Common | Gifts | |
| Water Pail Leash | Uncommon | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Water Soaking Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts | |
| Water Wings | Common | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Wishing Star | Rare | Puss in Boots | |
| Witches Wand | Uncommon | Halloween 2018 | |
| Wooden Pogo | Common | Gifts | |
| Wreath Frisbee | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Zombie Buffalo Plush | Uncommon | Halloween 2018 | |
| Zombie Finger Rattle | Common | Halloween 2022 |
