| Name | Rarity | Origin | |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Airplane Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Amber Bone | Uncommon | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Ammonite Frisbee | Uncommon | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Angelic Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards |
 | Anna Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Armchair Float | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Astro Ball | Ultra-Rare | Pet Shop |
 | Axe Rattle | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 |
 | Balloon | Rare | Gifts |
 | Balloons | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Banana Plush | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Banana Pogo | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Banana Rattle | Common | Baby Shop |
 | Banjo | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 |
 | Bauble Balloon | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Bone Throw Toy | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Bone Xylophone | Rare | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Bongos | Uncommon | Campground |
 | Boomerang Throw Toy | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Briefcase Ingredient | Rare | Monkey Fairground |
 | Bubblegum Machine Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Bunny Plush | Uncommon | Easter 2019 |
 | Burger Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Cactus Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts |
 | Cactus Plushie Chew Toy | Common | Gifts |
 | Candle | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Candy Cane Chew Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2020 |
 | Candy Cane Ornament | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Candy Cane Pogo Stick | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Candy Cannon | Legendary | Halloween 2018 (Robux) |
 | Carrot Rattle | Uncommon | Easter 2019 |
 | Cat Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Caticorn Rattle | Common | Gifts |
 | Celestial Leash | Common | Gifts |
 | Chew Ball | Common | Gifts |
 | Chick Plush | Rare | Easter 2019 |
 | Chinese Lantern | Uncommon | Chinese New Year 2018 |
 | Chocolate Bunny Balloon | Rare | Easter 2019 |
 | Christmas Ball Ornament | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Christmas Cat Rattle | Rare | Gifts |
 | Christmas Doge Rattle | Common | Christmas 2017 |
 | Christmas Star Frisbee | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Claw | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Clouds & Rainbow Rattle | Rare | Baby Shop |
 | Clown Umbrella | Uncommon | Monkey Fairground |
 | Controller Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Cookie Dough Plush | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Cookie Frisbee | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Cool Frisbee | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Creator Rattle (Bethink) | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Creator Rattle (NewFissy) | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Creepy Balloon | Common | Halloween 2019 |
 | Croc Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Crossbow Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2019 |
 | Crown Frisbee | Rare | Gifts |
 | Crystal Ball Rattle | Uncommon | Halloween 2020 |
 | Cymbal Ingredient | Rare | Monkey Fairground |
 | Da Vinci Propeller | Rare | Star Rewards |
 | Daisy Flying Disc | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Dandelion Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Spring Festival 2020 |
 | Didgeridoo | Rare | Star Rewards |
 | Discosplosion | Ultra-Rare | Robux |
 | Dog Food Frisbee | Common | Gifts |
 | Dog Leash | Rare | Gifts |
 | Doge Rattle | Common | Baby Shop |
 | Donut Frisbee | Rare | Gifts |
 | Donut Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Donut Throw Toy | Ultra-Rare | Pet Shop |
 | Dragon Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Drone Propeller | Uncommon | Star Rewards |
 | Duck Balloon | Rare | Gifts |
 | Duck Rattle | Common | Baby Shop |
 | Easter Bunny Plush | Rare | Easter 2019 |
 | Egg Rattle | Uncommon | Easter 2018 |
 | Elephant Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Elf Ornament | Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Elf Plush | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Elf Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Eyeball Rattle | Common | Halloween 2020 |
 | Fancy Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Fancy Umbrella | Rare | Gifts |
 | Ferris Wheel Propeller | Rare | Halloween 2019 |
 | Festive Bells Balloon | Rare | Winter 2021 |
 | Festive Holly Propeller | Rare | Winter 2021 |
 | Festive Snow Globe Rattle | Uncommon | Winter 2021 |
 | Figgy Pudding Chew Toy | Common | Winter 2021 |
 | Flashlight | Uncommon | Campground |
 | Floaties | Common | Pool Store |
 | Floppy Bunny Plushie | Common | Toy Shop |
 | Flower Frisbee | Uncommon | Spring Festival 2020 |
 | Flower Rattle | Common | Gifts |
 | Flying Broomstick | Legendary | Halloween 2018 |
 | Flying Disc Umbrella | Common | Gifts |
 | Flying Saucer Disc | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Football Pet Toy | Rare | Pet Shop |
 | Founder's Key Throw Toy | Uncommon | Sunken Ship |
 | Frisbee | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Frostbite Grapple | Rare | Star Rewards |
 | Fun Frisbee | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Futuristic Grapple | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards |
 | Galaxy Flying Disc | Common | Gifts |
 | Galaxy Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Gift Stack Pogo Stick | Rare | Winter 2021 |
 | Gift Throw Toy | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Gingerbread Heart Flying Disc | Uncommon | Winter 2021 |
 | Glider | Ultra-Rare | Robux |
 | Glyptoball | Uncommon | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Golden Maned Unicorn Rattle | Ultra-Rare | Baby Shop |
 | Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Toy Shop |
 | Griffin Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Guitar | Rare | Campground |
 | Halloween Black Bat Propeller | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 |
 | Halloween Black Victorian Candlestick Rattle | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 |
 | Halloween Orange Pumpkin Balloon | Common | Halloween 2021 |
 | Halloween Orange Pumpkin Flying Disc | Common | Halloween 2021 |
 | Halloween Orange Pumpkin Voodoo Doll | Rare | Halloween 2021 |
 | Halloween White Ghost Balloon | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 |
 | Halloween Wooden Scythe Grappling Hook | Rare | Halloween 2021 |
 | Heart Balloon | Common | Toy Shop |
 | Heart Plushie | Common | Valentine's 2018 |
 | Heart Rattle | Common | Valentine's 2019 |
 | Holiday Breadstick Chew Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2020 |
 | Horse Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Hotdog Stand | Ultra-Rare | Robux |
 | Huggable Pillow | Common | Gifts |
 | Hugging Egg | Rare | Easter 2018 |
 | Hypnotic Frisbee | Uncommon | Monkey Fairground |
 | Ice Club Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Ice Cream Plush | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Ice Cream Rattle | Common | Gifts |
 | Ice Pick Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Inflatable Sword | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Inner Tube | Common | Pool Store |
 | Jackhammer | Rare | Gifts |
 | Kangaroo Pogo | Rare | Gifts |
 | Key Chew Toy | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Lavender Bundle | Uncommon | Spring Festival 2020 |
 | Lazy Float | Common | Pool Store |
 | Lead Zeppelin Balloon | Common | Gifts |
 | Leash | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Lemonade Stand | Ultra-Rare | Robux |
 | Lime Slice Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Llama Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Llama Rattle | Uncommon | Baby Shop |
 | Long Neck Throw Toy | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Lunar Pogo | Rare | Lunar New Year 2021 |
 | Lunar Rattle | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2021 |
 | Lunar Stroller | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Magic Door | Ultra-Rare | Robux |
 | Magic Wand Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts |
 | Magical Princess Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Magical Princess Leash | Rare | Gifts |
 | Marsh Balloon | Rare | Gifts |
 | Marsh Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Medieval Grapple | Uncommon | Star Rewards |
 | Mermaid Float | Uncommon | Pool Store |
 | Money Rattle | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Monkey Pogo | Rare | Monkey Fairground |
 | Monkey Propeller | Ultra-Rare | Monkey Fairground |
 | Mouse Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Mouse Leash | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Musical Conch | Common | World Oceans Day |
 | Newspaper Chew Toy | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Noob Balloon | Rare | Gifts |
 | Octopus Plush | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Ornament Throw Toy | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Panda Frisbee | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Panda Pal | Uncommon | Chinese New Year 2018 |
 | Peppermint Disc | Common | Christmas 2020 |
 | Phoenix Plush | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Pink Cat Balloon | Rare | Gifts |
 | Pizza Float | Rare | Pool Store |
 | Plate of Food Disc | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Plunger Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Pogo Stick | Common | Toy Shop |
 | Poinsettia Leash | Common | Winter 2021 |
 | Polar Bear Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Pool Noodle | Common | Pool Store |
 | Potato Chew Toy | Rare | Gifts |
 | Princess Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Propeller | Rare | Toy Shop |
 | Protein Bottle Rattle | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Pumpkin | Rare | Halloween 2017 |
 | Pumpkin Rattle | Common | Halloween 2017 |
 | Puppy Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Rabbit Rattle | Common | Easter 2019 |
 | Rainbow Rattle | Rare | Gifts |
 | Rainbow Wand | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Rattle | Common | Baby Shop |
 | Raw Bone | Common | Pet Shop |
 | Reindeer Leash | Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Reindeer Ornament | Legendary | Christmas 2019 |
 | Reindeer Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Rib Guitar | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 |
 | Rocket Grappling Hook | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Rocket Pogo | Rare | Gifts |
 | Rope Chew Toy | Rare | Gifts |
 | Rose Pogo | Rare | Gifts |
 | Rubber Bone Throw Toy | Common | Pet Shop |
 | Rubber Chicken Rattle | Rare | Gifts |
 | Rubber Dog Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Santa Leash | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Santa Ornament | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Santa Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Satellite Balloon | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Scroll Ingredient | Ultra-Rare | Monkey Fairground |
 | Shoe Chew Toy | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Shuttle Pogo | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Skeleton Pogo Stick | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 |
 | Skull Drum | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 |
 | Sleigh Bell Throw Toy | Uncommon | Winter 2021 |
 | Sleigh Bells Rattle | Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Snowball Launcher | Common | Christmas 2020 |
 | Snowflake Frisbee | Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Snowflake Ornament | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Snowman Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Snowman Rattle | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Soccer Ball Throw Toy | Common | Gifts |
 | Sock Chew Toy | Common | Christmas 2019 |
 | Soda Chew Toy | Common | Gifts |
 | Space Grappling Hook | Rare | Gifts |
 | Sparkler | Uncommon | Campground |
 | Spider Grappling Hook | Rare | Halloween 2020 |
 | Spinning Propeller | Rare | Toy Shop |
 | Squeaky Bone | Common | Pet Shop |
 | Squeaky Spikey | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Squid Plush | Common | Gifts |
 | Squid Rattle | Uncommon | Baby Shop |
 | Staff Ingredient | Legendary | Monkey Fairground |
 | Standard Grappling Hook | Ultra-Rare | Toy Shop |
 | Standard_Pogo | Common | Toy Shop |
 | Star & Moon Propeller | Rare | Halloween 2020 |
 | Star Ball | Rare | Pet Shop |
 | Star Balloon | Common | Toy Shop |
 | Star Ornament | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 |
 | Starpower Wand | Uncommon | Gifts |
 | Steel Drum | Uncommon | Star Rewards |
 | Stegosaurus Throw Toy | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Stick Throw Toy | Common | Gifts |
 | Sun Balloon | Common | Gifts |
 | Sunflower Rattle | Common | Spring Festival 2020 |
 | T-Rex Rattle | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | T-Rex Throw Toy | Common | Fossil Isle Excavation |
 | Tangerine Chew Toy | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2021 |
 | Teddy Bear | Common | Toy Shop |
 | Teddy Skele | Rare | Halloween 2017 |
 | Telescope Pogo | Rare | Gifts |
 | Tennis Ball | Uncommon | Pet Shop |
 | Throwing Pumpkin | Uncommon | Halloween 2019 |
 | Tombstone Ghostify | Rare | Halloween 2018 |
 | Top Hat Frisbee | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Trumpet | Uncommon | Star Rewards |
 | Turkey Leg | Common | Gifts |
 | Turkey Plush | Uncommon | Thanksgiving 2019 |
 | Unicorn Leash | Ultra-Rare | Pet Shop |
 | Unicorn Plush | Ultra-Rare | Gifts |
 | Unicorn Rattle | Uncommon | Baby Shop |
 | Venus Fly Trap Rattle | Common | Gifts |
 | Witches Wand | Uncommon | Halloween 2018 |
 | Wooden Pogo | Common | Gifts |
 | Wreath Frisbee | Rare | Christmas 2019 |
 | Zombie Buffalo Plush | Uncommon | Halloween 2018 |
