| Name | Rarity | Origin | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ace Goose Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| African Painted Dog Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Agender Rat Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Amber Bone Sticker | Uncommon | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Ankylosaurus Sticker | Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Arctic Tern Sticker | Common | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Aromantic T-Rex Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Axolotl Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Balloon Unicorn Sticker | Legendary | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Bat Dragon Cuddle Animated Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Bat Dragon Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Beaver Sticker | Common | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Bee Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Bi Dodo Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Blue Betta Fish Sticker | Legendary | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Blue Dog Sticker | Common | Task Board | |
| Brachiosaurus Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Bullfrog Sticker | Common | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Capricorn Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Castle Hermit Crab Sticker | Uncommon | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Chameleon Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Chick Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Copper Pickaxe Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Corn Doggo Sticker | Ultra-Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Cow Calf Sticker | Uncommon | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Cow Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Dalmatian Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Deinonychus Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Demisexual Bat Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Diamond Ladybug Sticker | Legendary | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Diamond Pickaxe Sticker | Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Dilophosaurus Sticker | Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Dimorphodon Sticker | Legendary | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Dinner Discourse Cat Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Dodo Sticker | Legendary | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Dog Sticker | Common | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Donkey Sticker | Common | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Dragon Breath Animated Sticker | Legendary | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Dragon Sticker | Legendary | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Elasmosaurus Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Elephant Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Fallow Deer Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Flamingo Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Flying Fish Sticker | Common | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Fossil Sticker Pack | Rare | Fossil Isle 2024 | |
| Fox Sticker | Uncommon | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Frog Sticker | Uncommon | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Gay Snake in a Boot Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Gender Fluid Ghost Dog Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Genderqueer Seahorse Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Ginger Cat Sticker | Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Glyptodon Sticker | Uncommon | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Gold Penguin Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Goldhorn Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Ground Sloth Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Hamster Selfie Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Happy Clam Sticker | Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Happy Pride Zebra Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Hermit Crab Sticker | Common | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Hot Doggo Sticker | Ultra-Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Ice Cream Hermit Crab Sticker | Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Intersex Ringed Octopus Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Iron Pickaxe Sticker | Uncommon | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Kid Goat Sticker | Common | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Kitsune Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Kiwi Sticker | Uncommon | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Koala Sticker | Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Koi Sticker | Uncommon | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Ladybug Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Lamb Sticker | Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Lavender Dragon Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Leopard Shark Sticker | Common | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Lesbian Cat-Snake Alliance Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Leviathan Sticker | Legendary | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Lobster Sticker | Uncommon | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Long Neck Throw Toy Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Majestic Pony Sticker | Legendary | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Many Mackerel Sticker | Uncommon | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Mini Pig Sticker | Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Non-Beenary Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Ocelot Sticker | Uncommon | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Omnisex Pegasus Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Orange Betta Fish Sticker | Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Orange Butterfly Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Otter Sticker | Uncommon | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Pan Parrot Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Panda Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Parakeet Sticker | Common | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Parrot Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Pelican Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Penguin Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Pet Rock Sticker | Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Pets Plus Sticker Pack | Legendary | Pets Plus Subscription | |
| Phoenix Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Pig Sticker | Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Pink Betta Fish Sticker | Ultra-Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Pink Cat Sticker | Common | Task Board | |
| Pirate Hermit Crab Sticker | Ultra-Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Poodle Sticker | Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Premium Sticker Pack | Legendary | Toy Shop | |
| Pretty Please Snowball Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Pretty Pony Sticker | Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Pride Sticker Pack | Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Pterodactyl Sticker | Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Pudding Cat Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Puffin Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Punk Pony Stiker | Uncommon | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Queen Bee Sticker | Legendary | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Ram Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Rat Sticker | Uncommon | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Red Panda Sticker | Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Rodeo Bull Sticker | Uncommon | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Sabertooth Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Sasquatch Sticker | Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Seagull Yell Animated Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Seahorse Sticker | Uncommon | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Shark Puppy Sticker | Ultra-Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Shiba Inu Sticker | Uncommon | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Show Pony Sticker | Common | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Silly Duck Sticker | Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Sloth Sticker | Uncommon | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Space Whale Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Squid Sticker | Legendary | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Squished Red Pandorama Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Standard Sticker Pack | Common | Toy Shop | |
| Starfish Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| State Fair Sticker Pack | Uncommon | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Stegosaurus Sticker | Uncommon | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Stegosaurus Throw Toy Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Strawberry Shortcake Bat Dragon Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| T-Rex Rattle Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| T-Rex Sticker | Legendary | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| T-Rex Throw Toy Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Tasmanian Tiger Sticker | Common | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Tortuga De La Isle Sticker | Ultra-Rare | State Fair Sticker Pack | |
| Toucan Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Trans Glyptodon Barv Sticker | Rare | Pride Sticker Pack | |
| Triceratops Sticker | Uncommon | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Turtle Sticker | Ultra-Rare | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Unicorn Sticker | Legendary | Standard Sticker Pack | |
| Velociraptor Sticker | Uncommon | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Walrus Sticker | Uncommon | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Wet Owl Sticker | Legendary | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Winged Horse Sticker | Legendary | Premium Sticker Pack | |
| Wooly Mammoth Sticker | Rare | Fossil Sticker Pack | |
| Yule Log Dog Sticker | Rare | Pets Plus Sticker Pack | |
| Zebra Sticker | Rare | Standard Sticker Pack |
