| Name | Rarity | Origin | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 Uplift Butterfly | Uncommon | Adopt Me 4th Birthday | |
| 2022 Uplift Butterfly | Uncommon | Adopt Me 5th Birthday | |
| Abyssinian Cat | Rare | Desert Weather Map | |
| African Wild Dog | Ultra-Rare | UGC Rewards Update July 2023 | |
| Albatross | Ultra-Rare | Golden Clam | |
| Albino Bat | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 (Bat Box) | |
| Albino Gorilla | Legendary | Premium Gorilla Box | |
| Albino Monkey | Legendary | Monkey Fairground | |
| Alicorn | Legendary | Regular Egg | |
| Alley Cat | Ultra-Rare | Urban Egg | |
| Alpaca | Ultra-Rare | Farm Theme 2023 | |
| Amami Rabbit | Uncommon | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Ancient Dragon | Legendary | Regular Egg | |
| Angelfish | Common | Jungle Update 2023 | |
| Angler Fish | Uncommon | Danger Egg | |
| Ankylosaurus | Rare | Fossil Isle 2024 | |
| Ant | Common | Regular Egg | |
| Arctic Fox | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Arctic Hare | Uncommon | Hare Box | |
| Arctic Reindeer | Legendary | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Arctic Tern | Uncommon | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Armadillo | Common | Desert Egg | |
| Ash Zebra | Common | Ash Zebra Bait | |
| Astronaut Gorilla | Legendary | Gorilla Box | |
| Aussie Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Australian Kelpie | Rare | Aussie Egg | |
| Axolotl | Legendary | Robux | |
| Badger | Ultra-Rare | Fall Weather Update | |
| Baku | Legendary | Japan Egg | |
| Bald Eagle | Ultra-Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux) | |
| Bali Starling | Common | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Balloon Unicorn | Legendary | Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux) | |
| Banded Civet | Uncommon | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Bandicoot | Common | Aussie Egg | |
| Basilisk | Rare | Halloween 2022 | |
| Bat | Uncommon | Halloween 2020 (Bat Box) | |
| Bat Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2019 (Candy) | |
| Beaver | Rare | Retired Egg | |
| Bee | Ultra-Rare | Honey | |
| Beluga Whale | Common | Winter 2023 | |
| Billy Goat | Legendary | Urban Egg | |
| Binturong | Ultra-Rare | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Bird of Paradise | Rare | Jungle Update 2023 | |
| Birthday Butterfly 2023 | Uncommon | Adopt Me 6th Birthday | |
| Birthday Butterfly 2024 | Uncommon | Adopt Me 7th Birthday | |
| Black Chow-Chow | Legendary | Golden Bone | |
| Black Kite | Ultra-Rare | Urban Egg | |
| Black Macaque | Ultra-Rare | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Black Marlin | Uncommon | Sunshine Games 2024 | |
| Black Moon Bear | Rare | Lunar New Year 2023 (Moon Bear Box) | |
| Black Panther | Uncommon | Jungle Egg | |
| Black Springer Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | Easter 2022 | |
| Black-Chested Pheasant | Legendary | Golden Wheat | |
| Blazing Lion | Legendary | Campfire Cookie | |
| Bloodhound | Rare | UGC Pet Refresh January 2023 | |
| Blue Betta Fish | Legendary | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Blue Dog | Uncommon | Blue Egg | |
| Blue Egg | Rare | Easter 2019 | |
| Blue Jay | Rare | Garden Egg | |
| Blue Ringed Octopus | Ultra-Rare | Danger Egg | |
| Bluebottle Fly | Common | Urban Egg | |
| Border Collie | Rare | Spring Fest 2023 (Robux) | |
| Borhyaena Gigantica | Uncommon | Danger Egg | |
| Brachiosaurus | Common | Fossil Isle 2024 | |
| Brown Bear | Rare | Jungle Egg | |
| Brown Springer Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | Easter 2022 | |
| Brown-Chested Pheasant | Ultra-Rare | Golden Wheat | |
| Buffalo | Common | Retired Egg | |
| Bullfrog | Common | Woodland Egg | |
| Bunny | Rare | Retired Egg | |
| Burning Bunny | Ultra-Rare | Burnt Bites and Baked Alaska Baits | |
| Bush Elephant | Legendary | Sunshine Games 2024 (Robux) | |
| Business Monkey | Ultra-Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Cactus Friend | Legendary | Desert Egg | |
| Caelum Cervi | Legendary | Pride Update 2023 (Robux) | |
| Camel | Uncommon | Regular Egg | |
| Canada Goose | Uncommon | Farm Theme 2023 | |
| Candy Cane Snail | Ultra-Rare | Easter 2024 | |
| Candy Hare | Legendary | Hare Box | |
| Candyfloss Chick | Legendary | Easter 2024 (Robux) | |
| Capricorn | Legendary | Spacehome Update 2022 (Robux) | |
| Capuchin Monkey | Rare | Capuchin Fairground 2024 | |
| Capybara | Uncommon | Jungle Egg | |
| Cassowary | Rare | Jungle Update 2023 | |
| Castle Hermit Crab | Rare | Hermit Crab Box | |
| Cat | Common | Retired Egg | |
| Caterpillar | Ultra-Rare | Farm Theme 2023 (Robux) | |
| Cerberus | Legendary | Halloween 2020 (Robux) | |
| Chameleon | Legendary | RGB Reward Box | |
| Cheetah | Legendary | Sunshine Games 2024 | |
| Chef Gorilla | Ultra-Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Chick | Common | Easter 2020 Egg | |
| Chickatrice | Uncommon | Halloween 2022 | |
| Chicken | Common | Farm Egg | |
| Chimera | Legendary | Halloween 2022 | |
| Chipmunk | Rare | September 2023 | |
| Chocolate Chip Bat Dragon | Legendary | Winter 2023 (Robux) | |
| Chocolate Chow-Chow | Legendary | Golden Bone | |
| Chocolate Labrador | Uncommon | Retired Egg | |
| Christmas Egg | Legendary | Christmas 2019 | |
| Christmas Future Egg | Uncommon | Winter 2023 | |
| Christmas Pudding Pup | Ultra-Rare | Christmas Pudding Pup Bait | |
| Classic Teapot | Common | Roblox Classic Event 2024 | |
| Clownfish | Ultra-Rare | Ocean Egg | |
| Cobra | Legendary | Robux | |
| Cockroach | Common | Urban Egg | |
| Corgi | Ultra-Rare | Regular Egg | |
| Corn Doggo | Legendary | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Cow | Rare | Farm Egg | |
| Cow Calf | Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Coyote | Common | Desert Egg | |
| Crab | Uncommon | Ocean Egg | |
| Cracked Egg | Common | Nursery | |
| Criosphinx | Legendary | Desert Egg | |
| Crocodile | Ultra-Rare | Jungle Egg | |
| Crow | Legendary | Farm Egg | |
| Cuddly Candle | Legendary | Sky Castle Refresh 2023 (Robux) | |
| Cute-A-Cabra | Uncommon | Halloween 2023 | |
| Dalmatian | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 (Robux) | |
| Dancing Dragon | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2022 | |
| Danger Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Deathstalker Scorpion | Ultra-Rare | Desert Egg | |
| Deinonychus | Ultra-Rare | Fossil Egg | |
| Desert Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Diamond Albatross | Legendary | Golden Clam | |
| Diamond Amazon | Legendary | Golden Plantain | |
| Diamond Butterfly | Legendary | Golden Leaf | |
| Diamond Dragon | Legendary | Diamond Egg | |
| Diamond Egg | Legendary | Star Rewards | |
| Diamond Griffin | Legendary | Diamond Egg | |
| Diamond Hamster | Legendary | Golden Corn | |
| Diamond Hummingbird | Legendary | Golden Petunia | |
| Diamond King Penguin | Legendary | Ice Cream Shop Update | |
| Diamond Ladybug | Legendary | Diamond Lavender | |
| Diamond Mahi Mahi | Legendary | Mahi Spinning Rod | |
| Diamond Unicorn | Legendary | Diamond Egg | |
| Dilophosaurus | Rare | Fossil Egg | |
| Dimorphodon | Legendary | Fossil Isle 2024 | |
| Dingo | Uncommon | Aussie Egg | |
| Dire Stag | Legendary | Halloween 2023 | |
| Dodo | Legendary | Fossil Egg | |
| Dog | Common | Retired Egg | |
| Dolphin | Uncommon | Ocean Egg | |
| Donkey | Uncommon | Regular Egg | |
| Dotted Eggy | Rare | Easter Eggy Box | |
| Dracula Fish | Uncommon | Ocean Event 2024 | |
| Dracula Parrot | Legendary | Halloween 2024 | |
| Dragon | Legendary | Retired Egg | |
| Dragonfly | Legendary | Regular Egg | |
| Drake | Uncommon | Farm Egg | |
| Dugong | Common | Japan Egg | |
| Dylan | Uncommon | Wrapped Doll | |
| Easter 2020 Egg | Common | Easter 2020 | |
| Eel | Uncommon | September 2023 | |
| Eggnog Dog | Uncommon | Christmas Future Egg | |
| Eggnog Hare | Rare | Hare Box | |
| Elasmosaurus | Ultra-Rare | Fossil Isle 2024 | |
| Elephant | Rare | Safari Egg | |
| Emperor Gorilla | Legendary | Premium Gorilla Box | |
| Emu | Rare | Aussie Egg | |
| English Sheepdog | Rare | Farm Theme 2023 | |
| Ermine | Uncommon | Winter 2022 | |
| Evil Basilisk | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2022 | |
| Evil Chick | Legendary | Halloween Chick Box | |
| Evil Chickatrice | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2022 | |
| Evil Rock | Rare | Halloween 2023 (Robux) | |
| Evil Unicorn | Legendary | Halloween 2019 (Candy) | |
| Fallow Deer | Legendary | Woodland Egg | |
| Fanghorn Tortoise | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year Gift Boxes | |
| Farm Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Feesh | Rare | Meme Pets Update 2023 | |
| Fennec Fox | Uncommon | Retired Egg | |
| Field Mouse | Legendary | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Firefly | Legendary | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 (Robux) | |
| Flaming Fox | Ultra-Rare | Burnt Bites and Baked Alaska Baits | |
| Flaming Zebra | Rare | Flaming Zebra Bait | |
| Flamingo | Ultra-Rare | Safari Egg | |
| Fleur De Ice | Legendary | Winter 2023 | |
| Floral Eggy | Ultra-Rare | Easter Eggy Box | |
| Flower Power Duckling | Ultra-Rare | Duckling Box | |
| Flying Fish | Common | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Fool Egg | Legendary | April Fools Day 2023 | |
| Fossa | Uncommon | Jungle Update 2023 | |
| Fossil Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Frankenfeline | Common | Halloween 2024 | |
| Frog | Ultra-Rare | Aussie Egg | |
| Frogspawn | Uncommon | Meme Pets Update 2023 | |
| Frost Dragon | Legendary | Christmas 2019 (Robux) | |
| Frost Fury | Legendary | Christmas 2020 (Robux) | |
| Frost Unicorn | Legendary | Mountain House Update (Robux) | |
| Garden Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Garden Snake | Common | Garden Egg | |
| Gargoyle | Legendary | Urban Egg | |
| Gecko | Rare | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Ghost | Common | Halloween 2023 | |
| Ghost Bunny | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2020 (Candy) | |
| Ghost Chick | Ultra-Rare | Halloween Chick Box | |
| Ghost Dog | Rare | Halloween 2023 | |
| Ghost Wolf | Rare | Halloween 2022 (Wolf Box) | |
| Giant Anteater | Rare | Jungle Update 2023 (Robux) | |
| Giant Black Scarab | Ultra-Rare | Mud Ball | |
| Giant Blue Scarab | Ultra-Rare | Mud Ball | |
| Giant Gold Scarab | Legendary | Mud Ball | |
| Gila Monster | Uncommon | Desert Egg | |
| Ginger Cat | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Gingerbread Hare | Ultra-Rare | Hare Box | |
| Gingerbread Mouse | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2023 (Advent Calendar) | |
| Gingerbread Reindeer | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Giraffe | Legendary | Safari Egg | |
| Glacier Kitsune | Legendary | Winter 2023 (Robux) | |
| Glacier Moth | Ultra-Rare | UGC Pet Refresh January 2023 | |
| Glormy Hound | Legendary | Galactic Pass (Shards) | |
| Glormy Leo | Legendary | Galactic Pass (Shards) | |
| Glyptodon | Uncommon | Fossil Egg | |
| Goat | Ultra-Rare | Pride Event 2022 (Robux) | |
| Gold Mahi Mahi | Ultra-Rare | Mahi Spinning Rod | |
| Golden Albatross | Legendary | Golden Clam | |
| Golden Chow-Chow | Legendary | Golden Bone | |
| Golden Dragon | Legendary | Golden Egg | |
| Golden Egg | Legendary | Star Rewards | |
| Golden Griffin | Legendary | Golden Egg | |
| Golden Hamster | Legendary | Golden Corn | |
| Golden Hummingbird | Legendary | Golden Petunia | |
| Golden Jaguar | Ultra-Rare | Dia De Los Muertos 2024 | |
| Golden King Penguin | Legendary | Ice Cream Shop Update | |
| Golden Ladybug | Legendary | Diamond Lavender | |
| Golden Penguin | Legendary | Golden Goldfish | |
| Golden Rat | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2020 (Rat Box) | |
| Golden Tortoise Beetle | Legendary | Vault | |
| Golden Unicorn | Legendary | Golden Egg | |
| Golden Walrus | Legendary | Christmas 2021 | |
| Goldfish | Rare | Pool Store 2023 Update | |
| Goldhorn | Legendary | Mythic Egg | |
| Goose | Rare | Spring Fest 2023 (Robux) | |
| Gorilla | Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Grave Owl | Ultra-Rare | Dia De Los Muertos 2024 | |
| Green Amazon | Ultra-Rare | Golden Plantain | |
| Green Butterfly | Legendary | Golden Leaf | |
| Green-Chested Pheasant | Legendary | Golden Wheat | |
| Griffin | Legendary | Robux | |
| Grim Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2024 (Robux) | |
| Grinmoire | Ultra-Rare | Sky Castle Refresh 2023 | |
| Ground Sloth | Common | Fossil Egg | |
| Groundhog | Ultra-Rare | Groundhog Day 2024 | |
| Guardian Lion | Legendary | Robux | |
| Halloween Black Mummy Cat | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Blue Scorpion | Uncommon | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Evil Dachshund | Rare | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween Golden Mummy Cat | Legendary | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween White Ghost Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2021 (Robux) | |
| Halloween White Mummy Cat | Rare | Halloween 2021 | |
| Halloween White Skeleton Dog | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2021 | |
| Hamster | Ultra-Rare | Golden Corn | |
| Happy Clam | Ultra-Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Happy Duckling | Rare | Duckling Box | |
| Hare | Rare | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Harp Seal | Uncommon | Winter 2023 | |
| Hawk | Legendary | Woodland Egg | |
| Headless Horse | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2024 | |
| Hedgehog | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2019 (Gingerbread) | |
| Hermit Crab | Uncommon | Hermit Crab Box | |
| Highland Cow | Ultra-Rare | Scottish Pets Update 2023 | |
| Hippo | Rare | Danger Egg | |
| Honey Badger | Ultra-Rare | UGC Rewards Update September 2024 | |
| Horse | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Hot Doggo | Legendary | Summer Festival 2023 (Robux) | |
| Hummingbird | Ultra-Rare | Golden Petunia | |
| Husky | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Hydra | Ultra-Rare | Mythic Egg | |
| Hyena | Rare | Safari Egg | |
| Ibex | Rare | May 2022 | |
| Ibis | Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Ice Cream Hermit Crab | Ultra-Rare | Hermit Crab Box | |
| Ice Golem | Legendary | Christmas 2021 (Robux) | |
| Ice Moth Dragon | Legendary | Winter 2022 | |
| Ice Wolf | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 (Robux) | |
| Indian Flying Fox | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2024 | |
| Indian Leopard | Rare | Urban Egg | |
| Inmate Capuchin Monkey | Ultra-Rare | Capuchin Boxes | |
| Irish Elk | Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Irish Water Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | UGC Rewards | |
| Japan Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Jekyll Hydra | Legendary | Halloween 2024 (Robux) | |
| Jellyfish | Ultra-Rare | UGC Rewards Update January 2024 | |
| Jousting Horse | Legendary | Halloween 2022 | |
| Jungle Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Kangaroo | Legendary | Aussie Egg | |
| Karate Gorilla | Ultra-Rare | Gorilla Box | |
| Kid Goat | Common | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| King Bee | Legendary | Honey | |
| King Penguin | Ultra-Rare | Ice Cream Shop Update | |
| Kirin | Uncommon | Mythic Egg | |
| Kitsune | Legendary | Robux | |
| Kiwi | Rare | September 2023 | |
| Koala | Ultra-Rare | Aussie Egg | |
| Koi Carp | Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Komodo Dragon | Ultra-Rare | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Kookaburra | Ultra-Rare | Aussie Zone Update | |
| Kraken | Legendary | Ocean Event 2024 | |
| Ladybug | Ultra-Rare | Diamond Lavender | |
| Lamb | Ultra-Rare | Easter 2021 | |
| Lammergeier | Ultra-Rare | Danger Egg | |
| Lava Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2022 (Robux) | |
| Lava Wolf | Legendary | Halloween 2022 (Wolf Box) | |
| Lavender Dragon | Legendary | DJ Gamepass Compensation | |
| Leopard Cat | Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Leopard Shark | Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Leviathan | Legendary | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Liger | Common | Danger Egg | |
| Lion | Ultra-Rare | Safari Egg | |
| Lion Cub | Ultra-Rare | Safari Update 2023 (Robux) | |
| Lionfish | Ultra-Rare | Ocean Event 2024 | |
| Llama | Ultra-Rare | Farm Egg | |
| Lobster | Uncommon | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Longhorn Cow | Rare | Farm Theme 2023 | |
| Lunar Gold Tiger | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2022 (Lunar Tiger Box) | |
| Lunar Moon Bear | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2023 (Moon Bear Box) | |
| Lunar Ox | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year 2021 (Ox Box) | |
| Lunar Tiger | Rare | Lunar New Year 2022 (Lunar Tiger Box) | |
| Lunar White Tiger | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year 2022 (Lunar Tiger Box) | |
| Lynx | Rare | Christmas 2020 (Gingerbread) | |
| Magma Moose | Ultra-Rare | Campfire Cookie | |
| Magma Snail | Ultra-Rare | Campfire Cookie | |
| Mahi Mahi | Uncommon | Mahi Spinning Rod | |
| Majestic Pony | Legendary | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Malaysian Tapir | Common | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Maleo Bird | Common | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Maneki-Neko | Legendary | Japan Egg | |
| Many Mackerel | Ultra-Rare | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Marabou Stork | Rare | Halloween 2024 | |
| Mecha Meow | Legendary | Black Friday 2023 | |
| Mechapup | Legendary | Robux | |
| Meerkat | Uncommon | Safari Egg | |
| Merhorse | Rare | Mythic Egg | |
| Metal Ox | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2021 (Ox Box) | |
| Midnight Dragon | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2024 (Robux) | |
| Mini Pig | Ultra-Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 (Robux) | |
| Mole | Uncommon | Garden Egg | |
| Mongoose | Common | Urban Egg | |
| Monkey | Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Monkey King | Legendary | Monkey Fairground | |
| Moon Rabbit | Rare | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Moonlight Moth | Rare | Galactic Pass | |
| Mosquito | Common | Danger Egg | |
| Mouse | Common | Regular Egg | |
| Mule | Rare | Halloween 2022 | |
| Mushroom Friend | Legendary | Garden Egg | |
| Musk Ox | Rare | Christmas 2020 (Gingerbread) | |
| Mythic Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Naga Dragon | Legendary | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Narwhal | Rare | Ocean Egg | |
| Nautilus | Ultra-Rare | Beach Update 2024 (Robux) | |
| Nessie | Legendary | Scottish Pets Update 2023 | |
| Nightmare Owl | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2023 | |
| Ninja Monkey | Legendary | Monkey Fairground | |
| Nutcracker Squirrel | Rare | Winter 2023 | |
| Ocean Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Ocelot | Rare | Rain Weather Update | |
| Octopus | Legendary | Ocean Egg | |
| Orange Betta Fish | Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Orange Butterfly | Ultra-Rare | Golden Leaf | |
| Orangutan | Rare | Regular Egg | |
| Orca | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Ornate Horned Frog | Ultra-Rare | Leap Year 2024 | |
| Oryx | Rare | Desert Egg | |
| Ostrich | Rare | Safari Update 2023 | |
| Otter | Common | Retired Egg | |
| Owl | Legendary | Farm Egg | |
| Owlbear | Legendary | Danger Egg | |
| Ox | Rare | Lunar New Year 2021 (Ox Box) | |
| Panda | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Parakeet | Rare | Regular Egg | |
| Parrot | Legendary | Jungle Egg | |
| Peacock | Legendary | Robux | |
| Pelican | Ultra-Rare | September 2023 (Robux) | |
| Penguin | Ultra-Rare | Golden Goldfish | |
| Peppermint Penguin | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2023 (Robux) | |
| Peregrine Falcon | Ultra-Rare | Sunshine Games 2024 | |
| Persian Cat | Ultra-Rare | Puss in Boots | |
| Pet Egg | Rare | Nursery | |
| Phoenix | Legendary | Mythic Egg | |
| Pig | Rare | Farm Egg | |
| Pine Marten | Ultra-Rare | Woodland Egg | |
| Pink Betta Fish | Ultra-Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Pink Cat | Uncommon | Pink Egg | |
| Pink Egg | Rare | Special | |
| Piranha | Common | Danger Egg | |
| Pirate Ghost Capuchin Monkey | Legendary | Capuchin Boxes | |
| Pirate Hermit Crab | Legendary | Hermit Crab Box | |
| Pistachio | Uncommon | Wrapped Doll | |
| Platypus | Ultra-Rare | Jungle Egg | |
| Poison Dart Frog | Rare | Danger Egg | |
| Polar Bear | Rare | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Pomeranian | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards Refresh | |
| Poodle | Uncommon | Regular Egg | |
| Possum | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Praying Mantis | Ultra-Rare | Garden Egg | |
| Preppy Capuchin Monkey | Ultra-Rare | Capuchin Boxes | |
| Pretty Pony | Ultra-Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Princess Capuchin Monkey | Legendary | Capuchin Boxes | |
| Pterodactyl | Rare | Fossil Egg | |
| Pudding Cat | Rare | Fool Egg | |
| Puffer Fish | Ultra-Rare | Danger Egg | |
| Puffin | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Puma | Uncommon | Retired Egg | |
| Pumpkin Friend | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2024 | |
| Punk Pony | Rare | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Purple Butterfly | Ultra-Rare | Leaf | |
| Queen Bee | Legendary | Honey | |
| Quokka | Uncommon | Aussie Zone Update | |
| Rabbit | Rare | Retired Egg | |
| Raccoon | Uncommon | September 2023 | |
| Rainbow Dragon | Legendary | Lunar New Year Gift Boxes | |
| Ram | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Rat | Rare | Lunar New Year 2020 (Rat Box) | |
| Rattlesnake | Uncommon | Desert Egg | |
| Red Cardinal | Uncommon | Woodland Egg | |
| Red Crowned Crane | Ultra-Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Red Fox | Rare | Woodland Egg | |
| Red Panda | Ultra-Rare | Retired Egg | |
| Red Sand Dollar | Ultra-Rare | Pool Store 2023 Update (Robux) | |
| Red Squirrel | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Reindeer | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Retired Egg | Rare | VIP Room | |
| Rhino | Rare | Jungle Egg | |
| Rhino Beetle | Uncommon | Japan Egg | |
| Ribbon Seal | Ultra-Rare | Desert Weather Map | |
| Rice Cake Rabbit | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year Gift Boxes | |
| Ring-tailed Lemur | Rare | Jungle Update 2023 (Robux) | |
| River | Uncommon | Wrapped Doll | |
| Roadrunner | Ultra-Rare | Desert Egg | |
| Robin | Common | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Robo Dog | Legendary | Robux | |
| Robot | Ultra-Rare | Regular Egg | |
| Rock | Uncommon | April Fools Day 2022 | |
| Rock Pigeon | Uncommon | Urban Egg | |
| Rodeo Bull | Uncommon | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Rooster | Ultra-Rare | Farm Theme 2023 | |
| Rosy Maple Moth | Legendary | Garden Egg | |
| Royal Capuchin Monkey | Legendary | Capuchin Boxes | |
| Royal Corgi | Ultra-Rare | Royal Tea Party 2022 | |
| Royal Desert Egg | Legendary | Sphinx Statue Event | |
| Royal Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Royal Palace Spaniel | Ultra-Rare | Royal Tea Party 2022 (Robux) | |
| Sabertooth | Ultra-Rare | Fossil Egg | |
| Sado Mole | Common | Japan Egg | |
| Safari Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Salamander | Ultra-Rare | Woodland Egg | |
| Sandfish | Common | Desert Egg | |
| Sasquatch | Rare | Mythic Egg | |
| Scarebear | Legendary | Halloween 2024 | |
| Scarecrow | Uncommon | Halloween 2023 | |
| Scarecrow Cat | Ultra-Rare | Scarecrow Box | |
| Scarecrow Crow | Legendary | Scarecrow Box | |
| Scarecrow Horse | Rare | Scarecrow Box | |
| Scarlet Butterfly | Ultra-Rare | Leaf | |
| Sea Angel | Rare | Ocean Event 2024 | |
| Sea Skeleton Panda | Uncommon | Halloween 2024 | |
| Seagull | Ultra-Rare | Urban Egg | |
| Seahorse | Rare | Ocean Egg | |
| Shadow Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2019 (Robux) | |
| Shark | Legendary | Ocean Egg | |
| Shark Puppy | Legendary | Summer Festival 2023 | |
| Sheeeeep | Ultra-Rare | Meme Pets Update 2023 (Robux) | |
| Shetland Pony Dark Brown | Rare | Winter 2022 (Pony Box) | |
| Shetland Pony Light Brown | Legendary | Winter 2022 (Pony Box) | |
| Shetland Pony White | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 (Pony Box) | |
| Shiba Inu | Ultra-Rare | Retired Egg | |
| Show Pony | Common | Summer State Fair 2024 | |
| Shrew | Rare | Christmas 2019 (Gingerbread) | |
| Silly Duck | Uncommon | Farm Egg | |
| Singularity Beetle | Rare | Galactic Pass | |
| Singularity Pisces | Rare | Galactic Pass | |
| Skele-Rex | Legendary | Halloween 2020 (Candy) | |
| Skunk | Ultra-Rare | Garden Egg | |
| Slime | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2023 | |
| Sloth | Ultra-Rare | Robux | |
| Slug | Uncommon | Halloween 2022 | |
| Snow Cat | Uncommon | Retired Egg | |
| Snow Leopard | Uncommon | Christmas 2021 | |
| Snow Monkey | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2023 | |
| Snow Owl | Legendary | Christmas 2020 (Gingerbread) | |
| Snow Puma | Rare | Retired Egg | |
| Snowball Pet | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 (Robux) | |
| Snowman | Uncommon | Christmas 2020 (Gingerbread) | |
| Southeast Asia Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Space Whale | Ultra-Rare | Spacehome Update 2022 | |
| Spider Crab | Ultra-Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Spinosaurus | Legendary | Danger Egg | |
| Sprout Snail | Ultra-Rare | Fool Egg | |
| Squid | Legendary | RGB Reward Box | |
| St Bernard | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Starfish | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Starhopper | Rare | Galactic Pass | |
| Stegosaurus | Uncommon | Fossil Egg | |
| Steppe Lion | Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Stingray | Common | Ocean Egg | |
| Strawberry Shortcake Bat Dragon | Legendary | Winter 2022 (Robux) | |
| Striped Eggy | Legendary | Easter Eggy Box | |
| Sugar Axolotl | Legendary | Dia De Los Muertos 2024 (Robux) | |
| Sugar Glider | Legendary | Easter 2022 (Robux) | |
| Summer Walrus | Rare | Christmas 2021 | |
| Sunrise Duckling | Legendary | Duckling Box | |
| Swan | Rare | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Swordfish | Ultra-Rare | Regular Egg | |
| T-Rex | Legendary | Fossil Egg | |
| Tan Chow-Chow | Ultra-Rare | Golden Bone | |
| Tanuki | Uncommon | Japan Egg | |
| Tarsier | Rare | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Tasmanian Devil | Rare | Aussie Zone Update | |
| Tasmanian Tiger | Common | Fossil Egg | |
| Tawny Frogmouth | Uncommon | Urban Egg | |
| Therapy Dog | Uncommon | Great Ormond Charity Update | |
| Thorny Devil | Rare | Desert Egg | |
| Tio De Nadal | Legendary | April Fools Day 2023 (Robux) | |
| Toasty Red Panda | Ultra-Rare | Campfire Cookie | |
| Tortuga de la Isla | Ultra-Rare | Summer Festival 2023 (Robux) | |
| Toucan | Ultra-Rare | Star Rewards | |
| Toy Monkey | Ultra-Rare | Monkey Fairground | |
| Toy Poodle | Rare | Urban Egg | |
| Trapdoor Snail | Ultra-Rare | Japan Egg | |
| Tree Kangaroo | Legendary | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Triceratops | Uncommon | Fossil Egg | |
| Turkey | Ultra-Rare | Farm Egg | |
| Turtle | Legendary | Aussie Egg | |
| Undead Elk | Rare | Halloween 2023 | |
| Undead Jousting Horse | Legendary | Halloween 2022 (Robux) | |
| Unicorn | Legendary | Retired Egg | |
| Urban Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Urchin | Common | Ocean Event 2024 | |
| Vampire Dragon | Legendary | Halloween 2023 (Robux) | |
| Velociraptor | Uncommon | Fossil Isle 2024 | |
| Volcanic Rhino | Legendary | Burnt Bites and Baked Alaska Baits | |
| Vulture | Ultra-Rare | Desert Egg | |
| Walrus | Common | Christmas 2021 | |
| Warthog | Uncommon | Safari Update 2023 | |
| Water Moon Bear | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year 2023 (Moon Bear Box) | |
| Water Rabbit | Ultra-Rare | Lunar New Year 2023 | |
| Weevil | Rare | Garden Egg | |
| Werewolf | Legendary | Halloween 2022 (Robux) | |
| White Amazon | Legendary | Golden Plantain | |
| White Sand Dollar | Ultra-Rare | Pool Store 2023 Update (Robux) | |
| Wild Boar | Uncommon | Safari Egg | |
| Wildfire Hawk | Ultra-Rare | Burnt Bites and Baked Alaska Baits | |
| Winged Horse | Legendary | Robux | |
| Winged Tiger | Legendary | Lunar New Year 2023 (Robux) | |
| Wolf | Uncommon | Christmas 2019 (Christmas Egg) | |
| Wolpertinger | Common | Mythic Egg | |
| Wood Pigeon | Ultra-Rare | Spring Fest 2023 | |
| Woodland Egg | Legendary | Nursery | |
| Woodpecker | Rare | Woodland Egg | |
| Woolly Mammoth | Rare | Fossil Egg | |
| Wooly Rhino | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2022 | |
| Wrapped Doll | Legendary | Adopt a Doll Update | |
| Wyvern | Ultra-Rare | Mythic Egg | |
| Yellow Butterfly | Rare | Leaf | |
| Yellow-lipped Sea Krait | Uncommon | Southeast Asia Egg | |
| Yeti | Ultra-Rare | Christmas 2020 (Gingerbread) | |
| Yule Log Dog | Legendary | Fool Egg | |
| Zebra | Rare | Regular Egg | |
| Zodiac Minion Chick | Legendary | Zodiac Minion Egg | |
| Zodiac Minion Egg | Legendary | Minion Event 2022 | |
| Zombie Buffalo | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2019 (Candy) | |
| Zombie Chick | Rare | Halloween Chick Box | |
| Zombie Wolf | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2022 (Wolf Box) |
