| Name | Rarity | Origin | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anti-Gravity Potion | Uncommon | Sky Castle | |
| Apple | Common | Farm Shop | |
| Apple Pie | Common | Apple Pie Display Furniture | |
| Ash Zebra Bait | Common | Campfire Cookie | |
| Baby Bottle | Common | Baby Shop | |
| Baby Formula | Common | Baby Shop | |
| Baked Alaska Bait | Ultra-Rare | Fire Dimension 2024 (Robux) | |
| Big Brew Potion | Rare | Sky Castle | |
| Big Head Potion | Common | Sky Castle | |
| Blueberry Pie | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Broken Egg | Legendary | Easter 2019 | |
| Burger | Common | Supermarket | |
| Burnt Bites Bait | Common | Fire Dimension 2024 | |
| Cake | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Camper's S'more Treat | Uncommon | Camping Shop Refresh 2023 | |
| Candy Cane | Common | Christmas 2017 | |
| Candy Cane Cake | Common | Winter 2023 (Advent Calendar) | |
| Candy Corn | Common | Candy Cannon | |
| Cheese | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Chocolate | Common | Sweet Street 2018 | |
| Chocolate Drop | Common | Sweet Street 2018 | |
| Chocolate Egg | Common | Easter 2018 | |
| Chocolate Milk | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Chocolate Twist | Common | Sweet Street 2018 | |
| Christmas Pudding Pup Bait | Ultra-Rare | Winter 2023 (Advent Calendar) | |
| Cinnamon Roll | Uncommon | Fall Weather Update | |
| Coconut Drink | Uncommon | Rain Weather Update | |
| Coffee | Common | Coffee Shop | |
| Cookie | Common | Coffee Shop | |
| Cotton Candy | Common | Monkey Fairground | |
| Cotton Candy Stick | Common | Cotton Candy Stand | |
| Cure All Potion | Rare | Christmas 2019 | |
| Diamond Lavender | Legendary | Robux | |
| Dim Sum | Common | Chinese New Year 2018 | |
| Donut | Common | Furniture Catalog | |
| Flaming Zebra Bait | Rare | Campfire Cookie | |
| Fly-A-Pet Potion | Legendary | Robux | |
| Golden Bone | Legendary | VIP Update (Robux) | |
| Golden Clam | Legendary | Snow Weather Update (Robux) | |
| Golden Corn | Legendary | Pet Shop (Robux) | |
| Golden Goldfish | Legendary | Robux | |
| Golden Leaf | Legendary | Butterfly Sanctuary (Robux) | |
| Golden Petunia | Legendary | Pets Plus Subscription | |
| Golden Plantain | Legendary | Rain Weather Update (Robux) | |
| Golden Wheat | Legendary | Fall Weather Update (Robux) | |
| Green Tea Cup | Common | Furniture Catalog | |
| Grow Potion | Rare | Sky Castle | |
| Ham | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Healing Apple | Common | Hospital | |
| Heart Potion | Uncommon | Valentine's 2019 | |
| Honey | Legendary | Robux | |
| Honey Candy | Common | BEES! Blaster | |
| Hot Cocoa | Common | Hot Cocoa Stand | |
| Hot Dog And Fries | Common | Deep Fryer Furniture | |
| Hotdog | Common | Farm Shop | |
| Hyperspeed Potion | Common | Sky Castle | |
| Ice Cream | Common | Ice Cream Parlor | |
| Ice Lolly | Rare | Snow Weather Update | |
| Ice Tub | Common | Sweet Street 2018 | |
| Jasmine Tea Cup | Common | Furniture Catalog | |
| Knafeh | Rare | Desert Weather Map | |
| Leaf | Ultra-Rare | Butterfly Sanctuary | |
| Lemonade | Common | Lemonade Stand | |
| Levitation Potion | Ultra-Rare | Sky Castle | |
| Lollipop | Common | Candy Cannon | |
| Mac and Cheese | Common | Baking Dish - Mac and Cheese Furniture | |
| Mahi Spinning Rod | Common | Beach Shop | |
| Marshmallow On A Stick | Common | Campground | |
| Milkshake | Common | Milkshake Machine | |
| Molten Melon | Rare | Campfire Cookie | |
| Mooncake | Common | Near Bridge | |
| Mud Ball | Legendary | Desert Weather Map (Robux) | |
| Oolong Tea Cup | Common | Furniture Catalog | |
| Pancakes | Common | Pancake Maker Furniture | |
| Patterns Egg | Uncommon | Easter 2019 | |
| Pet Food | Common | Pet Shop | |
| Pet Treat | Uncommon | Pet Shop | |
| Pizza | Common | Furniture Catalog | |
| Popcorn | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Raspberry Pie | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Rice Cake Soup | Common | Lunar New Year Gift Boxes | |
| Ride-A-Pet Potion | Legendary | Robux | |
| Sandwich | Common | Signing In | |
| Seaweed | Common | World Oceans Day | |
| Small Sip Potion | Rare | Sky Castle | |
| Smores Cookie | Common | Campground | |
| Snowflake Cookie | Uncommon | Winter 2023 (Advent Calendar) | |
| Snowflake Potion | Uncommon | Christmas 2018 | |
| Soda | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Stars Egg | Uncommon | Easter 2019 | |
| Strawberry Shortcake | Common | Winter 2022 | |
| Stripes Egg | Uncommon | Easter 2019 | |
| Sugar Skull Potion | Ultra-Rare | Halloween 2024 (Robux) | |
| Sweet Rice Drink | Common | Lunar New Year Gift Boxes | |
| Taco | Common | Green Groceries | |
| Tea | Common | Coffee | |
| Tea Party Scone | Common | Tea Party Set | |
| Teleportation Potion | Uncommon | Christmas 2018 | |
| Translucent Tea Potion | Rare | Sky Castle | |
| Water | Common | Farm Shop | |
| Water Walking Potion | Rare | Sky Castle | |
| Watermelon | Common | Farm Shop |
